The One That Got Away

The One That Got Away is book 15 in the Gift Shop Mysteries series.

Sarah Morgan is shocked to find her aunt Nessie crying over a mysterious package. Inside she finds a piece of coral, a postcard, some nondescript rocks, a silver cup—and possible clues to the mystery of what happened to Randy Swanson, the man Aunt Nessie almost married fifty years ago! 

Sarah never knew about this fascinating, tragic story in her aunt’s life. Aunt Nessie explains that she once spent a summer working on a Caribbean island and fell in love with a man who explored old shipwrecks and searched for treasure. But shortly after they got engaged, he abruptly broke up with her and disappeared, never to be heard from again.

Aunt Nessie believes that the items in the box could only have come from Randy, whom she had feared dead. Yet it seems that may not be true, and he has reached out to her after all this time. Can Sarah find Randy—and uncover the reason why he shattered her aunt’s heart all those years ago?

About the Gift Shop Mysteries Series

Every gift tells a story…and some bring mysteries!

Get ready for a faith-filled mystery like no other! The excitement begins when Sarah Morgan returns to her picturesque hometown along the shore of Lake Huron to open a gift and curiosities shop, which she calls Heavenly Presents. As she reconnects with family and friends and grows in her faith, Sarah feels her shop becoming more than just a place to browse or buy. It’s turning into a cozy haven, where tucked among the handmade keepsakes and one-of-a-kind wonders are clues to long-buried secrets and surprising truths. Sarah soon discovers that solving small-town mysteries might just be the most meaningful gift she can offer.

Why You’ll Love the Gift Shop Mysteries Series:

If you’re looking for a mystery series that’s equal parts heartwarming and intriguing, Gift Shop Mysteries is your perfect next read. Set in a charming lakeside town with a faith-filled shop owner as your guide, each book offers:

• Captivating mysteries that keep you guessing—but never keep you up at night

• A cast of relatable, endearing characters who feel like old friends

• A cozy, small-town atmosphere you’ll want to escape to again and again

• Faith-filled encouragement and hope, gently woven through every story

• Themes of redemption, reconnection, and second chances—with God, family, and community

Plus, each book includes delightful extras:

• A recipe inspired by the story

• A personal letter from the author

• “Behind the Counter” insights into the real-life history or inspiration

• Book club-ready discussion questions

Whether you’re drawn to uplifting mysteries, enjoy uncovering meaningful secrets, or simply want a soul-soothing read with depth, heart, and a touch of suspense—this series was made for you.